Saturday, November 22, 2008     | Register
To start or answer a thread you will need to login...


Forum Guidelines

Please ensure you follow the bug-raising guidelines (e.g. post the full error from your Event Viewer) if you are raising a support call. To request a feature in a module, please use Feature Requests (unless you want to discuss it here in more detail first). If you have an urgent feature that you would like to see in the product then you should consider a Sponsored Enhancement.

 

First Time User? Make sure you have read the Module Config Guide in the documents folder of each module. Also check out this handy Module Deployment Guide (written by a Smart-Thinker customer!)

Configuration issues and no time to read the Forums/Documentation? See our DotNetNuke Premium Support Service.

 

We need your opinion! Please read our proposed new CrowdSourcing development method and let us know if you would be interested and if it might work.

 
 
  Forums  DotNetNuke  Smart-Thinker U...  using groups as filter for core forums module
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 10/13/2007 8:00 PM
  jpsanders
2 posts
No Ranking


using groups as filter for core forums module  (N/A)

I am new to dnn and have downloaded the trial version.  This appears to be what I am looking for.  Can you set up dnn forums to display usergroup topics and threads?  So group A would have their own forums, group b have theirs.  Also can it be set up so when a user goes to forums he first selects the group forum to view based upon the groups he is a member of?

Thanks.

 
New Post 10/13/2007 8:58 PM
  Rodney Joyce
2908 posts
www.DNNDir.com
1st Level Poster




Re: using groups as filter for core forums module  (Australia)

Hi,

No, unfortunately there is no integration with the DNN core forums - that module is completely unaware of the ST UserGroups module. I have some ideas for collaboration amongst group members but you would need to customize the core Forums module to do what you want.


Thanks
Rodney
See our modules in action on PokerDIY, a social network for home poker players

Smart-Thinker DotNetNuke Development Blog
 
New Post 10/14/2007 8:48 AM
  jpsanders
2 posts
No Ranking


Re: using groups as filter for core forums module  (N/A)

Here is what i am looking for.  I would like a place for my user groups to get together and comment on topics.  Anyone in the group could add topics and then everyone comment on them....I was thinking the forums would be a easy solution but I only want group members to be able to view the area.  Would there be a better way than forums, or if not, how much trouble am I looking at trying to modify the core module.

 
New Post 10/14/2007 3:10 PM
  Rodney Joyce
2908 posts
www.DNNDir.com
1st Level Poster




Re: using groups as filter for core forums module  (Australia)

This is actually a very common discussion I have with various people – group collaboration.

I use a temporary 3rd party solution on PokerDIY to try and solve this requirement– see

http://www.smart-thinker.com/Support/Forums/tabid/111/forumid/26/threadid/2990/scope/posts/Default.aspx

http://www.smart-thinker.com/Support/Forums/tabid/111/forumid/5/threadid/3644/scope/posts/Default.aspx

 

Bear in mind that the Forums were not built for this purpose – I would estimate about 2-3 weeks work to customize it to suit your needs, but this is an off-the-cuff guess – I have never looked at the Forum source so I don’t even know if it could be done. You could need to write the integration pieces into the module and start with a good design (which I would ask someone from the Forum module to have a look at before you start coding to make sure it is possible). Investigating the source and designing the solution will be half the work, and the coding/testing the other. It’s not a job I would undertake lightly – it’s going to be massive and tricky. Once you have built a dependency into the forum module (core or 3rd party) then your upgrade path resistance is increased and you’ll pay for this later when you upgrade.

 

It may be cheaper in the long run to code a custom “lite” version of the Forum to do what you want as opposed to modifying the forums. It depends on your requirements etc.


Thanks
Rodney
See our modules in action on PokerDIY, a social network for home poker players

Smart-Thinker DotNetNuke Development Blog
 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Forums  DotNetNuke  Smart-Thinker U...  using groups as filter for core forums module
Top Threads
In the past 1 week, we have 29 new thread(s) and 70 new post(s)
The most popular thread has been Re: Multipaid Sponsored Enhancements
The most active thread has been Multipaid Sponsored Enhancements / Crowdsourcing to improve modules
Smart-Thinker is powered by DotNetNuke - please support us and DotNetNuke - DotNetNuke Powered!
© 2008 Smart-Thinker   |  Privacy Statement  |  Terms Of Use